Cup of Joy Cafe, Too
Located in the heart of Rensselaer, Indiana, Cup of Joy Cafe, Too is more than just a coffee shop; it’s a warm embrace in your day. This charming spot at 215 W Washington St is renowned for its inviting ambiance and a menu that caters to both eclectic and classic coffee lovers alike. Whether you're arriving for a quick caffeine fix or seeking a cozy nook to savor quality time with friends, Cup of Joy offers an inviting atmosphere that is hard to resist.
The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a delightful decor that embodies warmth and comfort. Couches beckon you to sink in and stay awhile, with large tables accommodating group gatherings. The ambiance strikes the perfect balance between peaceful and lively, making it a fantastic choice for both quiet reflection and cheerful conversations. Patrons consistently rave about the friendly service and the inviting smiles that create an atmosphere you’ll want to return to time and again.
Now, let’s talk about the star of the show—the menu. From the classic drip coffee, crafted to perfection at just $2.25, to the indulgent mocha at $4.65, there’s something to suit every palate. Try a Wild Child Latte just like Hallie Johnson did—she raved about the combination of this unique drink with avocado toast topped with crispy bacon, deeming it 'to die for.' If you’re in the mood for something familiar yet special, you can't go wrong with their Cappuccino, priced at $4.10, or the delightful Breve that is a real treat at $5.85. Coffee aficionados will appreciate the various espresso-based drinks, including the Red Eye for a robust boost at $3.15.
For those who enjoy tea, Cup of Joy provides an enticing selection, with offerings such as Chai and Earl Grey that promise to satisfy your thirst for something warmer and soothing. The Cocoa Mocha is a must-try for chocolate lovers, delivering rich notes that complement the cafe's cozy ambiance.
Many customers have shared their experiences, with one, Samantha Joslyn, appreciating the delicious seasonal drinks and emphasizing the 'amazing service and always a smile on their faces.' This sentiment is echoed by Jason Theriault who described Cup of Joy as “the kind of coffee shop that instantly makes you smile,” commending its friendly vibe and delectable pastries that you simply need to sample.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to treat yourself to some quality time at Cup of Joy Cafe, Too. With everything from comforting drinks to an ambiance that feels like home, you'll leave with a smile and perhaps a renewed sense of joy. Enjoy your visit!
43 Reviews
28 Sep 2025
20 Sep 2025
18 Sep 2025
17 Sep 2025
16 Aug 2025
05 Aug 2025
03 Aug 2025
02 Aug 2025
Balkan Haus
Tiger Tiger
Warung'e PAKLEK
Raja's Curry House
Restaurant The Ben Arous
Join the Cup of Joy Cafe, Too Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.